Travis

   
ode to j.smith vs the man who
Craig
Posts: 162
Craig Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 11:56 AM Quote
for me ode to j.smith is the best travis album ive ever heard, even tops the man who in my opnion. which album out of these two do you think is the best?

 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
thehitcher
Posts: 292
thehitcher Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 11:58 AM Quote
I personally couldn't pick, they are both great albums
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
mili
Posts: 3258
mili Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 2:05 PM Quote
I'm having a Travis afternoon, playing all the albums.

I like them all very much. Ode and the Man Who are so different, I can't choose.
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
Kirsty McKenzie
Posts: 21
Kirsty McKenzie Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 2:14 PM Quote
i can choose easy haha ode to J. smith hands down, the man who is incredable obv but somethin bout the new album is just that bit beter, maybe its because its new and i cant stop lisening to it but who cares lol.
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
Kristy
Posts: 275
Kristy Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 2:19 PM Quote
Craig wrote:
for me ode to j.smith is the best travis album ive ever heard, even tops the man who in my opnion. which album out of these two do you think is the best?



they are two completely different albums and therefore cannot be compared IMO.



 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
BenFilbert
Posts: 3859
BenFilbert Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 2:33 PM Quote
I can't say until I've lived with Ode for longer. Get passed the 'new' feeling. At the moment I'm loving it. More than I did The Boy last year. I listen to Ode all the way through every day at the moment. I love it. :)
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
paul_c
Posts: 4170
paul_c Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 3:07 PM Quote
Incomparable
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
Bellringer
Posts: 92
Bellringer Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 11:41 PM Quote
The Man Who.

It's beyond just being another album. It's one of the greatest albums released. Quite incomparable in my opinion.

This isn't a criticism of Ode, it's just that the album never had it in itself to be legendary for me.
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
RUTHIEBABE00
Posts: 104
RUTHIEBABE00 Posted Wed 15 Oct, 2008 11:52 PM Quote
I can't compare like for like as they are both so different.. althought with true Travis style. I love them all and thank them for the MUSIC!!!!!!!

http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg239/KANGA001/dragon.gif
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
Cinthya Olguín
Posts: 44
Cinthya Olguín Posted Thu 16 Oct, 2008 12:20 AM Quote
Craig wrote:
for me ode to j.smith is the best travis album ive ever heard, even tops the man who in my opnion. which album out of these two do you think is the best?



That´s like traying to compare two Van Gohg paintings, simply immposible, unfruitful and pointless.
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
erikausagi
Posts: 765
erikausagi Posted Thu 16 Oct, 2008 4:34 AM Quote
the man who is my fav Travis CD ever... I discover them properly with this album... its too personal for me...

Ode to J Smith is completely different... and I mean, I'm still discovering after 20-30 plays?? i think i need more time for decide...
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
RaZzZ
Posts: 1287
RaZzZ Posted Thu 16 Oct, 2008 5:10 AM Quote
Is not the same, but i like much more songs in The man Who that Ode to J. Smith
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
adialurun
Posts: 7
adialurun Posted Thu 16 Oct, 2008 12:32 PM Quote
Ode is really good!
Like the new singing style & rockier sound ;-)

Of course The Man Who is also brilliant!
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
Mandy
Posts: 69
Mandy Posted Thu 16 Oct, 2008 4:53 PM Quote
Right now it's Ode but I think only time will tell which one is better to me personally. Ode is fresh in my ears but I'd like to see if it can last :) (tho Im sure it will, I do love it to bits!)
 
Re: ode to j.smith vs the man who
BenFilbert
Posts: 3859
BenFilbert Posted Thu 16 Oct, 2008 6:06 PM Quote
Mandy wrote:
Right now it's Ode but I think only time will tell which one is better to me personally. Ode is fresh in my ears but I'd like to see if it can last :) (tho Im sure it will, I do love it to bits!)


That's exactly how I feel too. :)
 
Pages [1] 2 Next All Times UTC Current Time 10:11 AM
Post Reply